Supreme Court rules in favor of "offensive" copyrights

20 June, 2017, 01:03 | Author: Michele Stevens
  • Supreme Court: 9/11 detainees can't sue top US officials

In a win for free speech, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled on Monday that trademarks can not be denied simply because a name is deemed offensive.

The justices ruled that the 71-year-old trademark law barring disparaging terms infringes free speech rights.

That rock band's name is the Slants - and its founder and bassist, an Asian-American named Simon Tam, argued that the band's name wasn't aimed at offending Asians in America.

Tam sought to register "The Slants" as a federally protected trademark shortly after puting the band together. As Justice Samuel Alito put it in a part of the opinion that all the justices joined, "If the federal registration of a trademark makes the mark government speech, the Federal Government is babbling prodigiously and incoherently".

The larger ramifications from this case are that the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office can not refuse trademarks it views as offensive. The government's arguments, Alito observed, boiled down to this: "The Government has an interest in preventing speech expressing ideas that offend".

The National Football League team, which took the name Redskins in the 1930s, filed a legal challenge to a 2014 decision by a U.S. Patent and Trademark Office tribunal canceling its trademarks as disparaging to Native Americans. The patent office argued that because federal trademarks can be enforced by government, they are effectively government-backed speech.

Snyder has said he would "NEVER" change the name.

Trump lashes out at 'bad,' 'conflicted' Russia investigators
Durbin, speaking on WGN radio, said he hoped the response to Trump firing Mueller would be bipartisan if it occurred. The Mueller investigation appeared to be reaching a broadening circle of current and former officials.

The band also hoped to trademark the name so they could protect themselves from fake merchandise and other products. Its rejection transformed the course of the band's career and brought them to nationwide attention: the ACLU called the ruling a "major First Amendment victory" on Monday, and in the months leading up to the decision, the Slants' story reached everywhere from NPR to the Washington Post to Billboard.

The band has said it wanted to reclaim what is often seen as a slur. To do so, he wrote, "is viewpoint discrimination in the sense relevant here: Giving offense is a viewpoint".

The Supreme Court heard the case on January 18.

The Redskins' attorney issued a statement (via the Washington Times) in response to the ruling, saying, in part, "The Team is thrilled with today's unanimous decision as it resolves the Redskins' long-standing dispute with the government. If affixing the commercial label permits the suppression of any speech that may lead to political or social 'volatility, ' free speech would be endangered".

In an email, Tam rejected the notion that upholding the gutted provision of the Lanham Act would hamper the Redskins' efforts to keep their name.

"For these reasons, we hold that the disparagement clause violates the Free Speech Clause of the First Amendment".

Government officials said the law did not infringe on free speech rights because the band was still free to use the name even without trademark protection.

Recommended:

  • Raid Battles, Gym changes and more special items to collect

    Raid Battles, Gym changes and more special items to collect

    After you've cleared out a gym of a team's Pokémon, they'll all return to their trainers and an egg will appear over the gym. Instead, every gym now has six permanent slots that anyone of the controlling team can fill with their Pokemon.

    Curry, Durant committed to keeping Golden State on top

    Owner Joe Lacob will be pulling out his pocketbook to potentially give Curry a $200 million deal. He won a championship, and then we were close and didn't win one.
    Ronaldo attracting the headlines after report he might leave

    Ronaldo attracting the headlines after report he might leave

    Mexico has won five of its last six matches , with a 2-1 home loss to Croatia in a friendly in May. There was later some doubt - and general confusion - over Soares' goal, which ultimately stood.
  • BJP Parliamentary Board to meet to finalise prez nominee

    BJP Parliamentary Board to meet to finalise prez nominee

    The presidential poll, which is scheduled for 17 July, will conclude on 20 July when the counting of the votes begins. BJP leaders are meeting leaders of various political parties to reach a consensus on presidential nominee.
    Kaepernick Compares Police Officers With Runaway Slave Patrol

    Kaepernick Compares Police Officers With Runaway Slave Patrol

    On Friday, a jury found him not guilty on all counts . "My son loved this city, and this city killed my son", said Valerie. The officer testified that Castile was pulling his gun out of his pocket despite his commands not to do so.

    Dodgers Puig suspended 1 game for obscene gesture to fans

    It was Robertson's first major-league home run and set up a one-out save for Dodgers closer Kenley Jansen . Lester brought up 150 career victories as he led the Chicago Cubs past the New York Mets 14-3.
  • Why the Internet Is Going Nuts Over Gal Gadot's Husband's Shirt

    Why the Internet Is Going Nuts Over Gal Gadot's Husband's Shirt

    In one memorable scene in the new film, Wonder Woman conceals a sword, known as the "Godkiller", in the back of her ball gown. Had a great time Friday visiting my brother, who is visiting Israel, got back, rested and took a shower...flawless Shabbat...
    Tech Titan CEOs Strategize at the White House

    Tech Titan CEOs Strategize at the White House

    In May, Trump created an " American Technology Council ", the latest in a series of efforts to modernize the US government. The White House official insisted that there has been "virtually no fallback" from Trump's Paris Agreement decision.
    US Open at a glance

    US Open at a glance

    He still built a six-shot lead through 36 holes, despite hitting his tee shot into the ocean on the 18th hole and salvaging bogey. AMERICAN Brian Harman has taken a dramatic third round by the scruff of the neck to lead the US Open at Erin Hills in Wisconsin.
  • Cosby accuser to resume testimony in sex assault trial

    Cosby accuser to resume testimony in sex assault trial

    So far, more than 50 women have come forward to accuse the former Cosby Show actor of drugging and sexually assaulting them. Cosby, 79, is charged with sexually assaulting Andrea Constand at his suburban Philadelphia estate in 2004.

    Wind howling as final round at Erin Hills gets under way

    Fleetwood began the day in a tie for second and made an encouraging start with a birdie from eight feet on the second. What truly stands out at Erin Hills is the site from the eighteenth tee, affectionately called, "Holy Hill".
    Protests over Minnesota police shooting result in 18 arrests on freeway

    Protests over Minnesota police shooting result in 18 arrests on freeway

    Castile's girlfriend, Diamond Reynolds , and her then four-year-old daughter were also in the auto when the officer shot Castile. The Star Tribune said those arrested included two reporters for other Minnesota newspapers who were covering the march .


Popular

Warriors fans celebrate, with expectations of more to come
For Stephen Curry and the rest of the returning Warriors, it was redemption for last year's upset loss to Cleveland in the Finals. The jubilant players hoisted the Larry O'Brien Trophy and gave high fives to their fans as confetti filled the air.

Warriors Green makes fun of Cavaliers
The brothers took turns climbing on top of a water cooler to see over the crowd and jumped with delight as Curry's bus went by. That sparked Golden State's push to sign Durant, who made a decision to leave his original team, the Oklahoma City Thunder.

Portugal and Mexico draw 2-2 in Confederations Cup
A few minutes after this, he was part of the build-up play which saw Portugal take a 2-1 lead late on. Too bad for Portugal as they left a stoppage time goal and Mexico earned a 2-2 draw.

Beaulieu welcomed Montreal trading him to Buffalo Sabres
He also opened the regular season on Montreal's top pairing with Shea Weber, but was quickly moved in favour of Alexi Emelin. Beaulieu's days with the Canadiens appeared to be numbered after the team signed KHL defenseman Jakub Jerabek back in May.

Worshippers hit by van at London mosque- Muslim Council of Britain
On June 3, three men drove a van into pedestrians on London Bridge , before launching a knife attack in nearby Borough Market. Monday. "Everybody was shouting: "A van's hit people, a van's hit people", a woman who lives opposite the scene told the BBC.